
This weekend was our
church's Oktoberfest celebration. Maranda headed up this annual fun fest complete with bake off. I don't have a photo of Miss Maranda but let me tell you she is a doll! Baby #1 is due in a matter of weeks and she still planned this super fun event without breaking a sweat. Her and Michael are going to be fabulous parents!
When I saw
Bakerella's recent post touting her latest mini creation
Pumpkin Pie Bites I knew they would be perfect for the Oktoberfest bake off. Yeah, I know, really twist my arm on that one. I would have baked them for Happy Tuesday if Oktoberfest wasn't this weekend. It doesn't take much when the words, "cute, baking, easy and seasonal" combine.
I only had to buy a couple of ingredients and the pumpkin cookie cutter. She says it's not necessary, but would you pass up cuteness if you saw it staring at you in the aisle? That's what I thought! I couldn't resist, either.

Tip #1: It looks HUGE for mini cupcakes, but it actually works really well. You'll see on her post how she stuffs it into the cups and makes it fit to perfection.

Do you know how much I love ready made pie crust? It saves SO much time when you are baking for cuteness rather than authentic made-from-scratch. My mom and sister make great scratch pie crust, but I haven't achieved that yet.
I did not have pumpkin pie spice, but sweet Bakerella told us it's a mixture of cinnamon, allspice, nutmeg and ginger. Check!
I added my own amounts, one small shake at a time, until I got it to the taste I liked. I put in probably 4-5 shakes of cinnamon, a few of nutmeg, a couple of allspice and a dash of ginger. It's all about your preference.

My spices are from
The Spice House. They certainly don't have to be, but let me just plug this spice oasis for a minute..or twelve.
See, I may be the luckiest little sister in the WHOLE world because Liz and Gavin live in Old Town, Chicago. As in, a couple blocks walk from the The Spice House. They gave Mr. Schalk and I the best wedding present ever 4 years ago....a whole box of various sweet and savory spices from The Spice House. Amazing! I've since gone through most of them - especially the taco seasoning. Yum!
If you don't have the luxury of being related to Liz and walking down the street on your visits, then you can order online. The Spice House has been raved about in many magazines, including Cooks Illustrated. They know their spices, extracts and flavors. If you have the time and interest, give a couple things a try and taste the difference yourself. I would suggest vanilla extract and Saigon Cassia Cinnamon. They really do make a difference, if you're into that kind of thing.

Along with adjusting the amount of spices I also added more pumpkin. I put in about 1 1/2 cups. I love pumpkin and thought it was not pronounced enough with just 1 cup as originally called for. As always, do what you enjoy! This recipe is so easy and quick that it's fun to make it your own.

Tip #2: Don't get so distracted by taking pictures that you forget the eggs until the 2nd batch. Who would do that? I have NO idea. Okay, I have a slight idea. What? I....uh...I got distracted.
I knew something was wrong when it took 20 minutes to set and still hadn't really set. I took the first batch out of the oven and was questioning what I did to goof up. They tasted good, but the texture was way off. You can't serve Punkin' Pie Pudding to people. That's just weird. So, don't forget those eggs! But if you do, know you're in good company.
I ended up using the rest of the pumpkin filling in mini cupcake papers since I was out of dough. I put some cream cheese icing and cinnamon on top and they were just fine.

I decorated the faces with brown tinted cream cheese. It was my friend Kaleena's suggestion after I was on the fence about the chocolate and pumpkin combo in Bakerella's recipe. I am sure it's tasty, but I just couldn't get on board. The cream cheese was a good idea and had the taste I was looking for. It also complimented the cream cheese in the filling. Tasty!
And without any further rambling....the recipe:

Pumpkin Pie Bites by the incredibly talented
Bakerella!
You can click the title above to find the original recipe. Below is the one I tweaked for my own preferences. Have fun making it your own!Pumpkin Pie Bites
By Bakerella with slight Moose tweaks
2 refrigerated ready-to roll pie crusts
8 oz. cream cheese, room temperature
1/2 cup sugar
1 1/2 cup canned pumpkin
3 eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla
1 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice (Or your own amounts of cinnamon, allspice, nutmeg and ginger)
Pumpkin-shaped cookie cutter
Optional
1/2 cup cream cheese
brown food coloring
re-sealable plastic bags
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Use cookie cutter to cut 12 pumpkin shapes from each pie crust. You will need to roll the dough thinner than it comes out of the box.
Press dough shapes into a 24 cup mini muffin tray. (Make 12 at a time, alternating cups to make sure pie crusts don’t overlap each other.)
Apply egg whites from one egg to the top edges of each pie.
Mix cream cheese, sugar, canned pumpkin, remaining 2 eggs, vanilla and pumpkin pie spice together until thoroughly combined.
Spoon mixture into each pumpkin-shaped pie crust.
Bake for 12-15 minutes.
Remove pies to cool and repeat with second pie crust. Place the muffin tray in the freezer to cool it quickly for re-use.
Makes 24 pies. Keep refrigerated.
To decorate, melt cream cheese in a heat-proof bowl in the microwave on medium. Heat for approximately 30 seconds until it is a drizzling consistency. Add brown food coloring if you are going for the authentic Jack 0' Lantern look. Just remember, people will think it's chocolate, so you may want to give them the heads up. Or you may not. Either way, transfer to a re-sealable plastic bag and cut the corner off. Drizzle or draw faces on pies.
Bakerella Note: The cutter I used was 3 3/4 inches wide, but if you don’t have one, don’t worry. Just use a round cutter around that size or slightly smaller to cut circle shapes out of the dough. Then make stems with the scraps. Press each stem over the edge and down the side of the dough before filling.

Happy October!
xoxo, Rachel